One of the biggest arguments for the candidacy of Barack Obama made by his supporters (including myself) is that he is an extremely smart guy. Obama's brainiac credentials are hard to dispute. He was born into a poor family, though he eventually moved in with his working class grandparents, and then made it to Columbia and Harvard Law School. At Harvard, he was the first black person to ever be made editor of the Harvard Law Review. He was a law professor for 11 years. He wrote two best selling books without the help of any ghostwriters, a feat which very few politicians can claim. So basically this Obama guy is pretty damn smart. Probably a genius. But do smart presidents neccesarily make good presidents?
Here is Wikipedias list of the best president's of
all time according to historians. The most recent one was done in 2005 by the Wall Street Journal, who seem to give a little more points to Reagan than the rest of them. But here is their rankings:
1) Washington
2) Lincoln
3) FDR
All the polls have these three guys at the top in some order. Hard to argue with those guys, though I would put Lincoln at the top. The list goes on:
4)Jefferson
5) The Teddy
All the polls seem to agree that these guys are 4 and 5 in some order. Now to the controversy:
6) Reagan
7) Truman
8) Eisenhower
9) Polk
10) Andrew Jackson
Two of these guys are considered extraordinarily intelligent: Jefferson and Lincoln. Some of them are considered (by me, granted) to be extremely smart: Washington, FDR, Teddy, Eisenhower (IQ: 122). Three of them are average: Reagan, Truman, and Polk. And one is half retarded: Jackson (though he was awesome at dueling, historians claim he successfully dueled with between 25 and 133 men).
Anyways, most of our great presidents are extremely smart. John McCain, though no G.W. Bush, is not extremely smart. He graduated 894 of 899 from the Naval Academy, and is old, and old people get dumber with age. You know why Marty Schottenhiemer doesn't have a job in the NFL anymore? Because he is old. But McCain does have courage, and like Jackson, Reagan, and Truman, he might be able to make up for the fact that he is not the sharpest guy in the Senate. Who knows. My bet is on the genius though.